To me, if Kiprusoff is available, and I believe he is for the right price, this is the best possible guy the Leafs could land.
Look at Kipper's numbers this year, he had amazing GAA and SV % and went 35 and 20 on a bad team. He's the reason they finished 9th in the West instead of 12th or 13th. He is among the most consistent goalies in hockey, and he's one of about 5 or 10 goalies count on to stand on his head and absolutely steal the odd game.
To get him I think it would cost a young player like a Kadri or Colborne, along with a young d-man (Schenn, Franson, or Blacker), and maybe an additional pick or player (2nd or 3rd rounder, or Frattin/Ashton/Kulemin).
I think some of you are under estimating his value. However I could be over valuing him, its hard to say, but I think the market for an established goalie of Kipper's calibre will be significant.